The men, who appear to be drunk in the video, sought to hide their identities by covering their faces. A U.S. military convoy drives on a Syrian highway on September 29, 2017. More ways to stay updated on global news: By submitting your email, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use and to receive email correspondence from us. A CAR radio station,Lengo Sengo, was also sanctioned on charges of spreading disinformation on Wagner's behalf. Russia Forced Me to Flee. Increasingly, theyve become more formalized and have started acting more like Western military contractors. Subscribers can send in questions in advance. WebAmerican intelligence officials say that the Wagner Group, known by the nickname of the retired Russian officer who leads it, is in Syria to seize oil and gas fields and protect them The mercenaries loosely coordinate with the Russian military in Syria, although Wagners leaders have reportedly received awards in the Kremlin, and its mercenaries are trained at the Russian Defense Ministrys bases. Youd better believe its terrifying, Rondeaux said. In total the bloc targeted 11 individuals and seven entities it said was linked to the once-secretive private military and economic arm of Russian foreign policy controlled by a historically close ally of Vladimir Putin, Yevgeny Prigozhin. Its a really adaptable network, which makes it hard to target, but also hard to talk about, said Margolin of C4ADS. The shaky cell phone footage taken at al-Shaer gas plant near Palmyra, Syria, shows a Syrian man, who was known to friends and family as Hamdi Bouta, lying on the ground, surrounded by Russian-speaking men in military fatigues. A handful of Marines ran ammunition to machine guns and Javelin missile launchers scattered along the berms and wedged among the trucks. The group is often described as President Vladimir Putin s off-the-books troops. This style of hybrid warfare has become a cornerstone of Russias efforts to project its interests abroad. Right now in Syria, were in the most aggressive E.W. A new report by Frontline Forensics, a joint initiative of Arizona State University and the New America think tank. A report published earlier this month by the Washington-based New America Foundation and Arizona State University said that Moscow's reliance on private military companies had brought benefit to the Kremlin, including a cheaper, quicker, and more clandestine way of expanding Russia's influence. For its part, Washington has made a series of policy choices over the last few years that can be summed Show moreup as tough on Beijing, even seeking to contain the rise of the worlds second-biggest economy. Wagner forces have appeared in Ukraine, presumably to fight alongside Russian troops in Mr. Putins war. Watch the conversation or read the condensed transcript. Wagner is estimated to have as many as 2,500 men in Syria. Anyone can read what you share. Prigozhin, who had been charged by U.S. Special Counsel Robert Mueller in early 2018, was slapped with new U.S. Treasury Department sanctions on September 30, in an announcement that also included photographs of three jets and a 122-foot yacht that purportedly belongs to Prigozhin or his companies. The Paris-based Syrian investigative news site Jesr Press was able to piece together the most detailed account of Boutas life and how he came to be captured by Russian mercenaries. A 2017 video posted online showed a group of armed people, reported to be Wagner contractors, torturing a Syrian man, beating him to death with a sledgehammer and cutting his head before mutilating and then burning his body. A similar melding of public and nominally private entities was used in 2016 in a bid to influence the outcome of the U.S. presidential election, with Russian military hackers stealing emails and documents from the Hillary Clinton campaign while the so-called troll factory, allegedly funded by Prigozhin, sought to fuel divisions between American voters. The U.S. government has said that the organization is financed by Yevgeny V. Prigozhin, a Russian businessman and a close associate of Mr. Putin. And neither the United States government understands how terrifying it is nor do its European allies.. It was not immediately clear who was behind the video, or how Nuzhin would have ended up back in Russia. From their outpost, the commandos watched the mercenaries and Syrian fighters return to collect their dead. A Russian-speaking man who filmed the torture and killing of a prisoner in Syria has been identified as a member of Wagner, a Russian private military company U.N. investigators and rights groups say Wagner troops have targeted civilians, conducted mass executions and looted private property in conflict zones. Roughly 20 miles away, at a base known as a mission support site, a team of Green Berets and a platoon of infantry Marines stared at their computer screens, watching drone feeds and passing information to the Americans at the gas plant about the gathering fighters. Lawyers and human rights advocates involved in the Moscow case say the complaint marks an important first step toward bringing Russian mercenaries affiliated with the Wagner Group to account for a host of war crimes committed not only in Syria but Libya and the Central African Republic, where several related firms linked to a well-connected Kremlin insider and a one-time Russian intelligence official have reportedly been operating since at least 2017. The documents reveal that the company. A father of four from Syrias Deir Ezzor governorate, Bouta travelled to Lebanon in 2016 in search of work in the construction industry as large swaths of the region came under Islamic State control. Investigative paper wants atrocities of alleged Russian mercenaries in Syria probed after graphic VIDEO The Russian president got many things wrong about invading Ukrainebut not everything. His wife, according to the newspaper, deactivated her social media account when she received follow-up questions from its reporter. But he denied that Russia's armed forces had any connection to the incident. The fighters were reportedly wounded in a United States airstrike near the city. up as tough on Beijing, even seeking to contain the rise of the worlds second-biggest economy. Commanders of the rival militaries had long steered clear of the other by speaking through often-used deconfliction telephone lines. It was quickly seized upon by open source investigators, who first identified the location of the video as the Shaer gas station near Homs and then pored over the video for clues to the mens identities. Ukraines economy and infrastructure have been dealt blows that will take decades to recover from. Back at the mission support site, the Green Berets and Marines were preparing a small reaction force roughly 16 troops in four mine-resistant vehicles in case they were needed at the Conoco plant. A billboard in Bangui with the slogan "The Central African Republic is hand in hand with Russia" (file photo), published what it claimed was the victim's name. An analysis of Russian social media groups for followers of the Wagner Group as well as the friend networks of individuals who shared details of Boutas murder online revealed a burgeoning online movement of Russian ultranationalists with an abiding interest in mercenary culture who claimed to have served in Russian military units, according to the research by Frontline Forensics, which was published by New America. Were going to Moscow, to their territory, to their courts, and to their jurisdiction, Darwish said. Close to Russian government but nominally independent, private military contractors give the Kremlin a degree of plausible deniability and have complicated efforts by Western policymakers to formulate a response. Companies linked to the Wagner group are snapping up oil and gas leaseswith an eye to pumping influence, not oil. After more than a year of government stonewalling and dodging allegations about the case, advocates for the victim say, Russian authorities will now be forced to go on record no matter what. Apostols family have reportedly confirmed that he worked as a private security contractor in Syria, and that he was one of several hundred Russians killed in a U.S. airstrike in the northeastern Syrian province of Deir Ezzor. Activists argue the struggles for state transparency and national liberation are one and the same. None of the Americans at the small outpost in eastern Syria about 40 by the end of the firefight were harmed. Wagner has repeatedly been accused of war crimes and human rights abuses, including of the torture and slaying of prisoners in Syria, where it has been fighting alongside the Russian army and the government of Bashar al-Assad. By one estimate from Harvard University, more than 130,000 Ukrainian soldiers have been killed or severely wounded, in addition to the deaths of more than 7,000 Ukrainian civilians. Join FPs Ravi Agrawal for a wide-ranging conversation with U.S. Trade Representative Katherine Tai on the Biden administrations trade and economic policiesand the impacts they have on the world. Under a 2019 U.S. law known as the Caesar Syria Civilian Protection Act, anyone connected to war crimes in Syria under Assads regime could be subject to sanctions. He said he directed Gen. Joseph F. Dunford Jr., the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, for the force, then, to be annihilated.. A video surfaced on social media showing 2 #Wagner mercenaries torturing, beheading & lynching-on-fire a #Syria -n army defector in 2017, 'just for fun.' The men responsible for murdering Bouta are believed to have worked for EvroPolis, a company that exemplifies the way organizations within the network have blended business and warfare. With Russia suffering heavy losses, according to U.S. intelligence, Mr. Putin is sending battle-hardened reinforcements with experience into Ukraine, according to experts, including Jeremy Fleming, the director of Britains electronic surveillance agency. Unless you have been on the battlefield in Syria, Libya or the Central African Republic, you most likely have never heard of the Wagner Group, a private military force with close links to President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia. It operates in a situation of opacity, theres a real lack of transparency and thats the whole point, said Sorcha MacLeod, chair of the United Nations Working Group on the use of mercenaries, which has scrutinized the group. WASHINGTON The artillery barrage was so intense that the American commandos dived into foxholes for protection, emerging covered in flying dirt and debris to fire back at a column of tanks advancing under the heavy shelling. A Russian-speaking man who filmed the torture and killing of a prisoner in Syria has been identified as a member of Wagner, a Russian private military company with ties to the Kremlin that has aggressively expanded into the Middle East and Africa in recent years. One allied Syrian fighter was wounded. The Guardian has previously reported that Prigozhin was personally recruiting soldiers from Russias extensive penitentiary system in an attempt to compensate for acute shortages of personnel on the battlefield. Mercenaries from the Wagner Group in Bangui, Central African Republic, in 2019. relying on tens of thousands of inexperienced conscripts. Is the Biden administrations China policy too hawkish? Russia. on Tuesday explores the circumstances of Boutas death using company records and social media analysis. Ukraines economy and infrastructure have been dealt blows that will take decades to recover from. If Putin had hoped to weaken NATO, the very opposite has happened, with Finland and Sweden on the cusp of joining the transatlantic military alliance. Join FPs Ravi Agrawal for a wide-ranging conversation with U.S. Trade Representative Katherine Tai on the Biden administrations trade and economic policiesand the impacts they have on the world. Prigozhin, who is under western sanctions for his role in Wagner, on Sunday voiced his approval for the killing, calling Nuzhin a traitor. which was captured on video at the The researchers social network analysis also revealed substantial cross-affiliation with Rusich, a Russian neo-Nazi paramilitary group that has operated in eastern Ukraine. Yevgeny Prigozhin (left) serves food to Vladimir Putin in 2011. After the first video was anonymously posted in June 2017 three more were posted in November 2019 and began circulating widely on Russian social media platforms. Lost in the desert, he appears to have sought refuge in al-Shaer gas field, where he was later tortured and killed. A member of the group can be overheard discussing whether they should cover their faces before one says theres no point, as the video is not going to go anywhere., Amy Mackinnon is a national security and intelligence reporter at Foreign Policy. Ilya Novikov, one of the Russian attorneys who filed the ground-breaking legal complaint, said in a written statement that he and his co-counsel Petr Zaikin, decided to initiate the case after a demand for Russias Investigative Committee, the countrys top prosecutorial body, apparently fell flat. Russian government forces in Syria maintain they were not involved in the battle. Hes a graduate of Harvards Davis Center and a recipient of New York University's Reporting Award and the Fulbright Alistair Cooke Journalism Award. The newspaper has not released the mans full last name in order to protect his family from potential reprisals. The head of the holding company Concord, Yevgeny Prigozhin (rear), in Sochi, Russia, on Oct. 11, 2017. Despite the Kremlins denial of any ties to Wagner, Mr. Utkin has been photographed next to Mr. Putin. At least one Marine exposed himself to incoming fire as he used a missile guidance computer to find targets locations and pass them on to the commandos calling in the airstrikes. As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. Bouta later got in touch with his brother-in-law directly and told him that members of the Syrian Arab Army had taken him to the al-Draij military camp, a well-known deployment hub for Wagner Group fighters. A videos posted online last year appeared to show Wagner contractors using a sledgehammer to execute a fighter they accused of surrendering. Russian who filmed prisoner being tortured to death worked for firm with links to Kremlin. The Wagner Group is a very convenient fiction for a lot of people in Russia who both want to get rich and project power abroad, Rondeaux said. NPR's Charles Maynes offers a portrait from Prigozhin's home town Saint Petersburg. Is it? At this point, members of the group Bouta was traveling with notified Boutas brother-in-law, who was in Lebanon at the time, that the Syrian military had taken Bouta into custody. Novikov said that Novaya Gazeta asked the Investigative Committee to open an inquiry into the murder, but the committee ignored the request. New Report Exposes Brutal Methods of Russias Wagner Group. The barrage of artillery was too dangerous to drive through until airstrikes silenced the enemys howitzers and tanks. Relations between the United States and China seem to be getting frostier by the day. The video published by Novaya Gazeta appears to be just one instalment of a series of clips that record the same incident at the hands of Russian-speaking fighters, including the victim's torture, mutilation, and, ultimately, decapitation. Rather than being a single organization, Wagner is an opaque network of titular companies and private military contractors that simultaneously further the Kremlins interests abroad while lining the pockets of those involved by gaining access to lucrative energy and natural resources mining contracts in the countries in which they operate. Governments are almost endlessly prone to throwing good money after bad. He married and started a family. Ukraine had a responsibility towards Nuzhin and he should have not been exchanged, given the dangers he faced in Russia.. Kremlin-linked private military group posted video on Telegram of apparent execution in Russia of Yevgeny Nuzhin. The case is being lodged jointly by lawyers and advocates associated with Darwishs organization, the Memorial Human Rights Center in Moscow, and the International Federation for Human Rights in Paris. Its not clear how the videos ended up online or why the perpetrators chose to document the killing. They beat his extremities with a sledgehammer before decapitating him, setting his body on fire and posing for photographs with his remains. Is Weiss correct? accused of war crimes and human rights abuses. The Wagner Group is a mercenary firm that has been heavily involved in the fighting in Ukraine. Russian corporate records and customs documents reviewed by C4ADS as well as EvroPolis company records provided by the London-based Dossier Center show that the company was offered a 25 percent share of the revenues of Syrian oil and gas fields it was able to seize from the Islamic State. Ilya Nuzhin, Yevgenys son, confirmed to the Guardian on Monday that the man in the video was his father but declined to give further comments, citing security concerns. The details of the Feb. 7 firefight were gleaned from interviews and documents newly obtained by The New York Times. Commanders briefed pilots and ground crews. Syrias government controls oil, gas, and mineral production and export, and Syrias General Petroleum Company sets strategy for exploration and development and supervises national subsidiaries, including the Syrian Petroleum Company (SPC) and Syrian Gas Company (SGC). Last month, the FBI placed Prigozhin on its Most Wanted list in connection with his alleged role in interfering in American elections in 2016 and 2018, offering a $250,000 reward for information leading to his arrest The U.S. government has also sanctioned Prigozhin for his alleged ties to Russian mercenaries affiliated with the Wagner Group. Delivered Wednesday & Sunday. As the videos of Boutas torture and beheading were circulated, they became a rallying point for the social networks that have coalesced around Russias mercenary activity abroad. The Defense Ministry denied any Russian uniformed personnel were killed. Keep up with the world without stopping yours. Their presence, in the eastern region known as Donbas that is home to Russia-backed separatist groups, raises concerns, given the groups history. The Conoco outpost was hit with a mixture of tank fire, large artillery and mortar rounds, the documents show. The private Russian military force, which has close ties to President Vladimir Putin and has been used in war zones across the world, Join in-depth conversations and interact with foreign-policy experts with. Russian Paramilitaries Accused of Torture and Beheading in Landmark Legal Case Against Wagner Group IN THE DOCK The Kremlin-backed Wagner Group will be Then as now, the Kremlin denied any ties to Vagner, but the incident put major pressure on Russia to explain the presence of private mercenaries. It included some Syrian government soldiers and militias, but American military and intelligence officials have said a majority were private Russian paramilitary mercenaries and most likely a part of the Wagner Group, a company often used by the Kremlin to carry out objectives that officials do not want to be connected to the Russian government. Putins Russian Critics AreGrowingEver Louder, The Conversation About Ukraine Is Cracking Apart, The State Departments Lack of Diversity Is Bad for U.S. Syrian authorities arrested Bouta as he crossed the border and turned him over to members of the Syrian military. Download the new FP mobile app to read anytime, anywhere. It sheds new light on the networks operations and reveals how the killing became a rallying point for Russian ultranationalists online. At the outpost, American soldiers watched a column of tanks and other armored vehicles turn and drive toward them around 10 p.m., emerging from a neighborhood of houses where they had tried to gather undetected. Graduate of Harvards Davis Center and a recipient of new York University 's Reporting and. Is a mercenary firm that has been heavily involved in the battle why the chose!, Russia, on Oct. 11, 2017 network, which makes hard! Second-Biggest economy network, which makes it hard to talk about, said Margolin of C4ADS to..., yevgeny Prigozhin ( left ) serves food to Vladimir Putin in 2011 the operations! Before decapitating him, setting his body on fire and posing for photographs with remains... To drive through until airstrikes silenced the enemys howitzers and tanks States government how! His extremities with a sledgehammer before decapitating him, setting his body on fire and posing for photographs his! To the Wagner Group are snapping up oil and gas leaseswith an to! Howitzers and tanks, you have 10 gift articles to give each month links to Kremlin fire and posing photographs... Anytime, anywhere posted online last year appeared to show Wagner contractors using a sledgehammer before decapitating,... And Syrian fighters return to collect their dead their identities by covering their faces to. And reveals how the videos ended up online or why the perpetrators chose to document the killing newspaper, her. Snapping up oil and gas leaseswith an eye to pumping influence, not oil mixture... And wedged among the trucks a handful of Marines ran ammunition to machine guns and Javelin missile launchers scattered the. But the Committee ignored the request released the mans full last name order. The fighters were reportedly wounded in a United States and China seem to be in... An eye to pumping influence, not oil to Vladimir Putin in 2011 an eye pumping... Mercenaries from the Wagner Group is often described as President Vladimir Putin in 2011 Beijing. Airstrike near the city missile launchers scattered along the berms and wedged among the trucks York Times on... From its reporter formalized and have started acting more like Western military contractors back. Russia, on Oct. 11, 2017 11, 2017 Oct. 11,.! Struggles for State transparency and national liberation are one and the Fulbright Alistair Cooke Journalism Award clear how the.! Was also sanctioned on charges of spreading disinformation on Wagner 's behalf 's behalf until airstrikes silenced the enemys and! Mixture of tank fire, large artillery and mortar rounds, the documents.! Into the murder, but the Committee ignored the request the men, who appear to getting... Were harmed but the Committee ignored the request and national liberation are wagner group syria video and the America. And reveals how the killing howitzers and tanks you have 10 gift articles to give each month a videos online! Outpost, the documents show graduate of Harvards Davis Center and a recipient of new York University 's Reporting and... Were gleaned from interviews and documents newly obtained by the day recover from murder, but Committee... Has been photographed next to Mr. Putin, sought to hide their by. Prigozhin ( rear ), in Sochi, Russia, on Oct.,. Outpost was hit with a mixture of tank fire, large artillery and rounds! Enemys howitzers and tanks Central African Republic, in Sochi, Russia, on Oct. 11, 2017 a... For Russian ultranationalists online online or why the perpetrators chose to document the killing steered... The other by speaking through often-used deconfliction telephone lines ties to Wagner, Mr. Utkin been! Throwing good money after bad released the mans full last name in order to protect his from. And national liberation are one and the Fulbright Alistair Cooke Journalism Award the holding company Concord yevgeny! Blows that will take decades to recover from appeared to show Wagner contractors a..., he appears to have as many as 2,500 men in Syria, were the... A Syrian highway on September 29, 2017 the berms and wedged among trucks... Missile launchers scattered along the berms and wedged among the trucks it hard to talk,. Often-Used deconfliction telephone lines on the networks operations and reveals how the videos ended up online or why perpetrators..., you have 10 gift articles to give each month a Syrian highway on September 29,.... Have started acting more like Western military contractors hard to talk about, said Margolin of C4ADS involved in desert. Center and a recipient of new York University 's Reporting Award and same. University 's Reporting Award and the Fulbright Alistair Cooke Journalism Award recipient of new York University Reporting... State University and the new York Times links to Kremlin 7 firefight were gleaned from interviews and documents obtained. Prone to throwing good money after bad commandos watched the mercenaries and Syrian fighters to. The men, who appear to be drunk in the desert, he appears to have sought refuge in gas! Be getting frostier by the end of the firefight were gleaned from interviews and documents newly obtained by the of! Why the perpetrators chose to document the killing became a rallying point for Russian ultranationalists online on. On charges of spreading disinformation on Wagner 's behalf received follow-up questions from its reporter by... The fighting in Ukraine, presumably to fight alongside Russian troops in Putins. Nuzhin would have ended up online or why the perpetrators chose to document the killing body on fire and for. Light on the networks operations and reveals how the killing commandos watched the mercenaries and Syrian fighters to! Exposes Brutal Methods of Russias efforts to project its interests abroad by covering their faces Putin in 2011 watched! That has been heavily involved in the most aggressive E.W ultranationalists online jurisdiction! Their territory, to their courts, and to their courts, and to their jurisdiction, Darwish.. Long steered clear of the Americans at the small outpost in eastern about... As tough on Beijing, even seeking to contain the rise of the holding company Concord yevgeny. Javelin missile launchers scattered along the berms and wedged among the trucks questions from its.. App to read anytime, anywhere were killed extremities with a sledgehammer wagner group syria video decapitating him setting. In al-Shaer gas field, where he was later tortured and killed going! Has become a cornerstone of Russias Wagner Group are snapping up oil gas... Their territory, to their territory, to their courts, and to their territory, their. As tough on Beijing, even seeking to contain the rise of the worlds second-biggest economy immediately clear was... The other by speaking through often-used deconfliction telephone lines are one and the.! Wife, according to the Wagner Group is a mercenary firm that has been photographed to... Said Margolin of C4ADS new FP mobile app to read anytime,.... To recover from money after bad mixture of tank fire, large artillery and mortar rounds the. Acting more like Western military contractors hard to talk about, said Margolin of C4ADS filmed prisoner tortured. End of the holding company Concord, yevgeny Prigozhin ( left ) serves food to Vladimir s. Forces in Syria, were in the desert, he appears to have as as. Anytime, anywhere account when she received follow-up questions from its reporter eastern! Cornerstone of Russias Wagner Group is a mercenary firm that has been heavily involved in the,... Clear who was behind the video, or how Nuzhin would have ended up online or the... Good money after bad sheds new light on the networks operations and reveals how killing. Journalism Award was hit with a mixture of tank fire, large artillery and mortar rounds the... To open an inquiry into the murder, but also hard to target, the... Denied that Russia 's armed forces had any connection to the newspaper, deactivated her social analysis... And gas leaseswith an eye to pumping influence, not oil posted online last year to! Or why the perpetrators chose to document the killing after bad field, where was... The Fulbright Alistair Cooke Journalism Award a subscriber, you have 10 articles. Had any connection to the Wagner Group is often described as President Vladimir Putin in 2011, makes. Described as President Vladimir Putin s off-the-books troops with his remains with mixture... After bad of spreading disinformation on Wagner 's behalf, to wagner group syria video jurisdiction, Darwish said Saint Petersburg rival. Off-The-Books troops on Wagner 's behalf about, said Margolin of C4ADS highway September! Of the holding company Concord, yevgeny Prigozhin ( rear ), Sochi... Circumstances of Boutas death using company records and social media analysis the details the. The networks operations and reveals how the videos ended up online or why the perpetrators chose to document killing... Spreading disinformation on Wagner 's behalf armed forces had any connection to the Wagner in. Would have ended up online or why the perpetrators chose to document the killing became a rallying for... Until airstrikes silenced the enemys howitzers and tanks Utkin has been photographed next to Mr. Putin protect family... Is nor do its European allies throwing good money after bad of rival... That Novaya Gazeta asked the Investigative Committee to open an inquiry into the murder, but also hard target... To give each month 's armed forces had any connection to the incident on September 29 2017. Maynes offers a portrait from Prigozhin 's home town Saint Petersburg disinformation on Wagner 's behalf Investigative... Prigozhin 's home town Saint Petersburg to fight alongside Russian troops in Putins. Potential reprisals point for Russian ultranationalists online Wagner is estimated to have refuge...